Spiegel Online (Germany) Interview
Mar-2009: Short interview (more “fact-checking”) to clarify some points that were being covered in an article about the correct way to tie shoelaces and avoid the “Granny Knot”.
Interview Details
Interviewed for:
Spiegel Online (Germany)- Interviewed by: Konrad Lischka
- Interviewed via: E-mail
- Interviewed on: 03-Mar-2009
Interview Transcript
KONRAD: Why do shoelaces come undone - is it just a question of the knot or also of material?
IAN: Shoelaces come undone more easily nowadays with some slippery synthetic shoelaces, especially nylon. However, the most common reason is the knot. Most people who suffer from shoelaces coming undone are using a “Granny Knot”.
The reason I know that it is the knot and not the material is that I almost never use anything more secure than the “Ian Knot”, yet my shoelaces never come undone, even with some of my shoes that have slippery synthetic shoelaces.
KONRAD: Is it true that flat shoelaces do not come undone as fast as the round ones?
IAN: That is true. The reason is probably that flat laces form a bigger bulge on either side of the knot, which holds the more compressed insides of the knot closed.
A simpler way of describing the difference is that round laces are more firm and stiff, so they don't form a nice tight knot.
KONRAD: What tricks do you advise people to use?
IAN: If someone is tying their knots correctly and still having problems, I usually advise that they replace the shoelaces. If they are willing to learn a more secure knot, that will also help enormously.
KONRAD: Is it true, that it helps to apply hair spray to the laces (no kidding, I read this on many German forums as an quite sincere advice)?
IAN: (*laughs*) I haven't heard this, but it does make sense! I've heard of other people using beeswax or even contact cement, which makes the shoelace sort of rubbery. Of course, this makes it much harder to tie as well.
Published Article
“Technikärgernis Schnürsenkel
Verflixt und zugeschnürt”
By Konrad Lischka, Spiegel Online (Germany), 07-Mar-2009
Article Transcript (English translation)
Technical annoyance: Shoelaces
Darned and tied up
Your shoelaces never hold? Then you're tying the wrong knots. Millions of people trip over their own feet because of this. Yet perfect shoe-tying techniques are easy to learn. Mathematicians have researched the best ones.
Paul Ives will never forget this sight - it was too funny: When the Brit came home from work last August, there was a man hanging in the smashed first floor window of his tranquil cottage in Dartford, UK. He was hanging upside down, by the laces of his sneaker, which had caught on the outside of the window frame. The man hanging in the living room had a hammer in his hand and swore to the police officers who had been called: “I was chasing a burglar.” Two months later, the burglar was convicted. The BBC ran the headline: “Hapless shoelace burglar jailed”.
You should tie your shoes properly, especially if you're a burglar.
The shoelace burglar is one of many news stories on the website of Ian Fieggen, an Australian computer tech who has been campaigning for years against shoelaces that open at the wrong moment. Some of the shoelace accidents in Fieggen's archive are absurd, many are tragic: People drown, get run over, crash their cars into buildings - all because of shoelace bows that open at the wrong moment.
This happens quite often - several times a day for me with some shoes, and even more often for other long-suffering people. A shoelace-bow victim complains on the web: “At work, I’m on the move almost all day, and every 20 minutes the laces on one of my shoes come undone.” Then the cry for help: “I'm really starting to have a crisis. Does anyone have a tip to make the laces hold better?”
Ian Fieggen has a couple. The 46-year-old programmer says he has been analyzing various methods for tying shoelaces since 1982, maintains what is probably the most comprehensive website on the subject, and has published one of the standard works on the subject (“Laces: 100s of Ways to Pimp Your Kicks”).
Slippery standard shoelaces
One reason why the bows on some shoelaces keep coming undone: The material. Fieggen: “This is much more common today, as many synthetic shoe laces are very smooth, especially nylon.” Helmut Farnschläder, President of the Central Association of German Shoemakers, observes this especially with standard shoelaces: “The vast majority of shoes come with factory-made laces that aren't made of pure cotton. The more synthetic the laces, the worse the knots hold. The companies that offer replacement laces take this into account.”
But even with such slippery standard laces, you can tie a fairly secure bow - with the right technique. Shoelace-bow expert Ian Fieggen explains: “The reason bows come undone is usually due to the knot. I know this because I use a special knot, and my shoe bows never come undone.”
The Granny Knot is all too loose
The most common mistake when tying shoes: People actually want to tie a bow with a Reef Knot (which would hold quite securely), but out of habit they make a Granny Knot, which comes undone much more easily. The mathematician David J. Green, who studies Knot Theory, explains it this way: “The Reef Knot and the Granny Knot look very similar, but are different. The traditional shoelace knot is a Reef Knot with two loops. However, some people have accidentally learned to tie a Granny Knot instead of a Reef Knot.”
Ian Fieggen describes the difference in great detail on his shoelace website. In diagrams, knots look very confusing at first, but the difference is actually quite simple: In the Granny Knot, the first knot has the same orientation as the second; in the Reef Knot, they are opposite. What this means in concrete terms can be seen with a little self-observation. For example, I intuitively tie my shoes like this: Left shoelace over the right, then an overhand knot, then a loop on the left and the right lace around the back.
But this is the perfect granny knot – twice on the left instead of once on the left and once on the right. The solution is quite simple: When tying the first knot, do not place the left lace over the right lace, but the other way around. On his website, Ian Fieggen has listed all the methods for tying a granny knot and added suggestions on how to correct these routines, which have been practiced day after day for years, with a minimal change.
The fact that it takes years for someone to realize that they learned the wrong bow-tying technique as a child astonishes many visitors to Fieggen's site. Some then write him emails, like Martin from the Netherlands, who discovered the shoe tying page in a mountain bike forum: “What a revelation. I'm 31 and my shoelaces have always come undone: Now (for the very first time) I know why.”
Ian Fieggen's Super Knot
To break a long-established Granny Knot routine, you have to tie your shoes very slowly and consciously for a few days. If you want, you can also invest this effort to learn a completely different loop knot. Ian Fieggen presents a few on his website, and even more can be found in the book “A Mathematical Guide to the Best (And Worst) Ways to Lace Your Shoes” by mathematician Burkard Polster.
Ian Fieggen has been lacing his shoes for years with his own invention, the “Ian Knot”. According to Fieggen, the knot is one of the most secure, looks neat and symmetrical, puts less strain on the material and - once learned - can be tied much faster than the conventional shoe bow. Fieggen: “It takes me a third of the time as for a regular knot.”
If that's true, you'll probably easily make up for the time it takes to learn the Ian Knot over the rest of your life - although that's still more difficult than breaking the habit of a granny knot. But after a few days, it works with almost the same routine you used to tie loose shoe bows for years. A bad habit that you should definitely eliminate.
After all, who wants to find themselves in the unpleasant situation of tripping over their untied shoelaces in a museum and smashing three Ming vases?









Software
Graphics
Ian
Chris
Tree