Crossed Ian Shoelace Knot
This knot is a curiosity that often results from tying the Ian Knot incorrectly. Twisting the loops in the wrong direction results in a knot with the ends crossed within the knot. It seems more secure – but can easily fall apart.
Begin with a regular Left-over-Right Starting Knot.
Make both ends into “loops” by simply doubling them back onto themselves. People often refer to these as “Bunny Ears”.
Unlike the regular Ian Knot, twist both loops clockwise so that the left (yellow) loose end is at the back and the right (blue) loose end is at the front.
The left (yellow) loop, which would naturally end up behind the right (blue) loop, is instead crossed back to the front, restoring it to the exact position that it would be in for the regular Ian Knot.
With everything back in position, this move is identical to that of the regular Ian Knot. Each hand uses the two fingers inside its own loop to grab the loose end of the other hand's loop.
This step is again identical to that of the regular Ian Knot. Each hand releases its own loop and pulls the loose end of the opposite loop through its own.
When pulled tight, the result is a perfectly symmetrical knot just like the regular Ian Knot with an extra crossover of lace ends in the middle. With practice, this can be tied almost as quickly as the regular method.
Finished Knot Gallery
The finished Crossed Ian Shoelace Knot looks very similar to the regular Ian Knot except for the additional crossover in the middle of the knot, which results in the loose ends exiting awkwardly to the front and rear of the knot.
Just as the Ian Knot uses the same core technique as the traditional “Tom Fool's Knot” (which appears in the definitive reference The Ashley Book of Knots as both #1141 and in more detail as #2534), the Crossed Ian Shoelace Knot uses the same core technique as the traditional “Handcuff Knot” (which in turn is shown as #412, #1134 and #1140). This knot is generally used to make “handcuffs” from a length of rope. The Crossed Ian Shoelace Knot could be described as a more intricate variant of the “Handcuff Knot”.
Is It A Worthwhile Knot?
Note that although this knot seems more secure than the regular Ian Knot when initially pulled tight, this is easily undone if the knot is disturbed. Even a slight tug to either of the loops or the loose ends will spill the crossover out of the knot, after which the knot falls apart just as easily as a regular shoelace knot.
In fact, The Ashley Book of Knots states:
“After the Handcuff Knot has been drawn up snugly, each end may be half hitched around one of the loops to render the knot secure.”
In other words, without this final step, the knot isn't secure.
Personally, I also don't like the way that the two loose ends stick out of the front and back of the knot instead of lying more naturally alongside the loops, as is the case with most other shoelace bows. It just doesn't look “neat”.
i would point out that the “crossed ian knot” is reffered to by some sources as a flemming shoelace knot (don't hold me to the spelling, but it's on animated knots by grog something similar).
– Brian P., Oct-2012
also, thanks for your shoe tying section, I figured out just yesterday that I was always tying my shoes wrong, but now I use your crossed Ian knot, because I can tie my shoes faster now, but also like your Halloween knot because it's fancy
– Emily L., Wisconsin, USA, Aug-2008
If you'd also like to send feedback, please Contact Ian.
Rate This Shoelace Knot
Please only vote once – multiple votes are removed daily